Skip to main content

Innovation Crossroads: Canada’s RDI Dilemma in Budget 2023

In an era defined by rapid technological advancements and global challenges like climate change, fostering a robust research and development (R&D) and innovation ecosystem is crucial for any nation’s economic growth and sustainability. At the heart of this pursuit lies the strategic allocation of resources to catalyze innovation. 

Canada’s Budget 2023 Allocation and Orientation: Striking the Right Balance 

Budget 2023‘s allocation, with 63% for social consumption initiatives and 37% for stimulating economic growth and investment, marks an improvement from the previous year. However, the focus on social initiatives raises concerns about Canada’s long-term economic prosperity. Strategic investments in innovation are crucial for building a strong innovation ecosystem and fostering economic competitiveness. While social consumption initiatives have their merits, neglecting innovation can hinder Canada’s ability to remain competitive in the global market. Without sustained commitment and forward-thinking policies, the nation risks missing out on opportunities in emerging industries and groundbreaking technologies. 

Budget 2023 Fiscal Impact Comprised Primarily of Social Measures

As the budget allocation for 2023 showcases an encouraging step towards addressing immediate priorities, it is paramount to delve into the broader implications, particularly in light of Canada’s standing in global R&D investment and innovation.

Global R&D Spending and Canada’s Position

Total global spending on R&D reached $2.48 trillion (USD, 2022), with China and the US dominating the landscape, accounting for 55% of combined investments. In contrast, Canada’s contribution stands at a mere 1.3% of global R&D investments, approximately $32 billion USD. This disparity is evident when comparing GOVERD (Government Expenditure on R&D) as a percentage of GDP, where Canada lags behind the OECD average and the United States, ranking 24th among OECD countries. Furthermore, Canada’s GOVERD spending relative to GDP is only half of the OECD average, raising concerns about its competitiveness and innovation potential. GOVERD is pivotal in driving a country’s innovation, economic growth, and competitiveness by supporting scientific research, technological advancements, and innovation across various sectors. However, the declining GOVERD funding trend poses challenges to Canada’s global standing and innovation capabilities.

Declining Government Expenditures on R&D (2000-21, % of GDP)

The Performance of Canada’s R&D and Innovation Ecosystem map for 2023 reveals a diverse array of federal programs supporting R&D and innovation. These programs play a pivotal role in shaping the nation’s technological landscape, propelling innovation, and fostering collaboration between various stakeholders.

Landscape of Federal Science Initiatives

The Federal government’s Science-based departments and agencies spend over $14 billion on science and technology activities in 2022-2023, over $8 billion on research and development and another $5.7 billion on related scientific activities – 54% of which was extramural and 46% was intramural expenditures. With a combined workforce exceeding 40,000 individuals entrenched in science and technology, there lies a potential for substantial contributions across diverse sectors. Further affirmation of the intention to foster innovation and technological advancements can be seen in the allocation of $2.65 billion for in-house R&D expenditures.

Federal Science-Based Departments and Agencies R&D Activity

However, there’s a notable transformation in the pipeline, as the Canadian Innovation Corporation prepares to take charge of the Industrial Research Assistance Program from the National Research Council of Canada. This transition brings both opportunities and questions about the program’s seamless integration and sustained efficacy.

Federal Programs: A Mixed Bag of Commitment and Omissions

The array of federal programs aimed at fostering innovation and research in Canada forms a critical part of the nation’s R&D ecosystem. Notably, the Strategic Innovation Fund (SIF) is allocated a substantial budget of $1.76 billion. However, concerns arise due to a mere $50 million earmarked for the new SIF-Strategic Innovation Fund in 2023-24. This allocation might limit the fund’s potential to catalyze innovation across diverse sectors.

Key Federal Programs Supporting Canada’s R&D/Innovation (2023-24 Main Estimates)

While Research Councils like NSERC, CIHR, and SSHRC continue to secure substantial funding, it’s important to note the constrained top-up funding allocated to them in recent budgets, indicating a potential deviation from the focus on Higher Education Research and Development (HERD) initiatives. However, a striking omission lies in the absence of financial support for the Global Innovation Clusters, a key proposition introduced in the 2022 Budget. The absence of such funding is puzzling, given that these clusters offer remarkable opportunities for fostering international collaboration, enhancing skill sets, and nurturing the growth of small and medium-sized enterprises.

The Power of the R&D and Innovation Ecosystem in 2023

As Canada aims to secure its competitive edge and address global challenges, recalibrating resource allocation and prioritizing innovation’s pivotal role is crucial. To thrive in the evolving landscape of R&D and innovation, a more strategic and comprehensive approach, backed by sustained commitment, is necessary.

The critical evaluation of the federal programs that shape Canada’s R&D landscape underscores the need for a balanced, forward-looking strategy. While the allocation of funds to various programs demonstrates a commitment to innovation, discrepancies in funding distribution, the absence of support for key initiatives like Global Innovation Clusters, and limited emphasis on sustainable development raise valid concerns.

By strategically distributing resources, fostering international collaboration, and integrating sustainable development goals, Canada can harness its potential as an innovation leader on the global stage. As we reflect on the nuances of the R&D and innovation ecosystem, the importance of addressing these critical aspects becomes even more apparent.

The Performance of Canada’s R&D and Innovation Ecosystem (2023) map provides invaluable insights that will shape the future of innovation in Canada. By optimizing policies and fostering partnerships, we can pave the way for a more sustainable and prosperous future. At Global Advantage Consulting, we are committed to fostering a collaborative and forward-thinking approach to unleash Canada’s innovation potential.

Contact us now to discover the power of Canada’s R&D and Innovation and its potential impact on your organization’s growth and success.

Related Content

Canada’s R&D Innovation Ecosystem Map 2023

July 2023

Education Across the OECD

October 2022